• Most Reliable Used SUVs

5 of the Most Reliable Used SUVs Recommended by Mechanics

February 26, 2026

What is the most reliable SUV to buy used? While no vehicle is completely maintenance-free, certain models stand out as the most reliable used SUVs thanks to proven engines, durable transmissions, and lower long-term repair costs. If you’re shopping for a reliable SUV used, the options below are five of the most reliable SUVs used that mechanics consistently recommend.

Here are five of the most reliable used SUVs (and why they’re such smart picks) if you’re trying to decide what is the most reliable used SUV for your budget and lifestyle.

1. Toyota 4Runner

The Toyota 4Runner is famous for long-term durability. Built on a truck-style body-on-frame platform, it’s designed for tough driving while remaining one of the most reliable used SUVs on the road.

Why mechanics recommend it

  • Proven V6 reliability
  • Strong transmission longevity
  • Excellent resale value
  • Often reaches 200,000+ miles with proper maintenance

If your top question is what is the most reliable used SUV for long-term ownership, the 4Runner is always on the shortlist.

2. Honda CR-V

The Honda CR-V is a go-to choice for buyers who want a practical, efficient, and reliable used SUV. It’s widely considered one of the most reliable used SUVs in the compact category.

Why it’s a reliable SUV used option

  • Dependable 4-cylinder engines
  • Lower average repair costs
  • Widely available replacement parts
  • Consistent reliability year after year

For many drivers looking for the best reliable used SUV for commuting and family use, the CR-V is a smart buy.

3. Lexus RX

If you want comfort without sacrificing reliability, the Lexus RX is one of the best answers to what is the most reliable SUV to buy used in the luxury segment. Lexus is Toyota’s luxury division, and the RX benefits from that proven engineering.

Why mechanics trust it

  • Toyota-engineered long-term reliability
  • Smooth, durable powertrains
  • Fewer major drivetrain failures than many luxury competitors
  • Strong longevity even with higher mileage

If you want a quiet, comfortable, and reliable used SUV, the Lexus RX is consistently one of the most reliable used SUVs mechanics see.

4. Toyota Highlander

The Toyota Highlander is a top family pick and one of the most reliable SUVs used for buyers who want three-row seating, daily comfort, and long-term durability.

What makes it one of the most reliable used SUVs

  • Proven Toyota powertrains
  • Strong automatic transmission reliability
  • Fewer recurring mechanical issues than many midsize SUVs
  • Great long-term ownership track record

If you’re comparing most reliable used SUVs for family driving, the Highlander is one of the most common mechanic-recommended choices.

5. Toyota RAV4

The Toyota RAV4 is one of the best-selling compact SUVs in the U.S. and a consistent standout among reliable used SUVs. For many shoppers, it’s one of the easiest answers to what is the most reliable SUV to buy used because it’s practical, efficient, and dependable.

Why mechanics recommend it

  • Proven 4-cylinder engine options
  • Excellent fuel efficiency
  • Low long-term ownership costs
  • Often surpasses 200,000 miles with proper maintenance

If you’re searching for the most reliable used SUV that balances value, reliability, and everyday usability, the RAV4 is one of the best reliable used SUV options available.

What Is the Most Reliable Used SUV Overall?

There isn’t one perfect answer to what is the most reliable used SUV — it depends on what you need most. Here’s a quick match-up:

  • Rugged durability: Toyota 4Runner
  • Efficiency + practicality: Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4
  • Luxury reliability: Lexus RX
  • Family space: Toyota Highlander

All five are widely considered most reliable used SUVs because they tend to hold up well over time when maintained properly.

What Makes an SUV Reliable?

When mechanics evaluate a reliable SUV used, they typically look at:

  • Engine longevity
  • Transmission durability
  • Cooling system reliability
  • Electrical system stability
  • Affordable parts and maintenance
  • Real-world performance past 150,000+ miles

Even the most reliable used SUVs still need regular oil changes, brake service, tire rotations, and timely fluid maintenance to stay dependable.

Before You Buy a Reliable Used SUV, Get It Inspected

Even if you’re buying one of the most reliable used SUVs, it’s smart to schedule a pre-purchase inspection. A used SUV can look great on the outside but still hide expensive problems underneath.

At Mike’s Auto Service in Newington, our technicians can:

  • Perform a full mechanical inspection
  • Check for engine and transmission concerns
  • Scan for diagnostic trouble codes
  • Inspect brakes, suspension, and steering components
  • Look for oil and coolant leaks

A pre-purchase inspection is one of the best ways to confirm you’re truly buying a reliable used SUV.

Need Help Choosing the Most Reliable Used SUV?

If you’re still wondering what is the most reliable SUV to buy used or want a trusted shop to inspect a potential purchase, we’re here to help.

Call Mike’s Auto Service in Newington to schedule a pre-purchase inspection and shop with confidence.

❯ Search:

❯ Follow Us: